Bonus BTT!

btt21 Bonus BTT!
Suggested by JM:

I was looking through books yesterday at the shops and saw all the Twilight books, which I know basically nothing about. What I do know is that I’m beginning to feel like I’m the *only* person who knows nothing about them.

Despite being almost broke and trying to save money, I almost bought the expensive book (Australian book prices are often completely nutty) just because I felt the need to be ‘up’ on what everyone else was reading.

Have you ever felt pressured to read something because ‘everyone else’ was reading it? Have you ever given in and read the book(s) in question or do you resist? If you are a reviewer, etc, do you feel it’s your duty to keep up on current trends?

Well, I realize that I already posted a BTT in anticipation of not being on line while on vacation… and I had every intention of not logging in today (my husband is golfing and my great task today is simply reading The Story of Edgar Sawtelle — which I am loving…).  However, our hotel in Colorado Springs just happens to have wonderful internet access and since my hubby is not here to say, “Blogging again?” I thought I would join in the BTT party!

I love this topic, especially since the questioner used the Twilight series as her example.  I recently read Twilight simply to find out what the buzz was about and enjoyed it.  However, I do not plan to read the rest of the series.  Which is how I approached Harry Potter years ago — I read the first three, enjoyed them, but didn’t continue on to the end.  I have also read a couple of Picoult‘s books, and would happily pick up another if stranded in an airport.

I definitely read works out of curiosity — I love to find out what is grabbing and holding our attention as readers.  And then I love to think about why certain authors are so popular.  I also feel a responsibility as a lit blogger to do so.  But, life is so short, and there are so many great books to read, that I usually just get a taste of what’s hot, and then move on.

On the other end of the spectrum (if we hypothetically place popular and critical tastes on opposite ends), I also love to read what the critics are excited about.  Like my current read — Edgar Sawtelle.  While I am loving this novel, I do not always agree with the critics, especially when they review “hip” choices written by my generation (Then We Came to the End comes to mind).  I don’t like self-consciously smart or snarky writing, unless it is done really really well for a greater purpose than proving the writer’s intelligence or hipness.  (However, that comment seemed a bit snarky, didn’t it!?).  However, I have yet to read a Pulitzer prize winner that I didn’t enjoy as well as respect.

Now, here’s my question for you — why wouldn’t you read what everyone else is talking about?  Feel free to leave me a comment and distract me from my reading until my husband returns and notices the laptop is on… again…  :)

Welcome back!

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

5 Comment(s)

  1. To answer your question (I talked about this in my answer) – I don’t always feel inclined to read what everyone else is talking about bc sometimes the hype ruins it for me – I think my expectations just get too high.

    S. Krishna | Sep 4, 2008 | Reply

  2. I guess I’m a rebel or something because I haven’t read the Twilight series or any Harry Potter books past the third one. I leave that for my husband…
    I’m not sure Edgar Sawtelle is really THAT popular – I think it might be in our circles…but not the mainstream. Not by a longshot. I did however, feel a little weird seeing Life of Pi in a mass market paperback on the rack at Safeway. It felt cheap actually.
    And since we mentioned Sawtelle – I loved it – finished it Saturday. Warning – don’t start up that third section at 10:00 pm!!!
    But no – I don’t follow the trends…which is maybe why I was still wearing leg warmers well past their “prime”…[sigh]

    Cynthia | Sep 4, 2008 | Reply

  3. Good tip about Edgar!! I’m right now in part IV and cannot put it down… I bet you’re right about it not being that popular yet, but word on the street is that it may be Oprah’s next pick, so that may change! :)

    Kristen | Sep 4, 2008 | Reply

  4. It took me awhile to track back to this post – but I just wanted to give you an example about what we may find to be popular in our literary bloggy circles but for the mainstream public – maybe not so…e.g., I just recorded three more podcasts last night (my two week writer’s block finally broke!) and the show’s producer said what she liked about my reviews is that I pick books outside of the mainstream…what books you ask? Edgar Sawtelle, End of the Alphabet and Mistress of the Art of Death. They had not heard of these books until now yet all of us feel like these books have been “done to death” – in fact, I almost didn’t do Edgar because of that. Ya just never know…

    Cynthia | Sep 19, 2008 | Reply

  5. When I was in university I read a lot of books and watched a lot of movies and tv shows that everyone else was watching just so that I didn’t feel totally out of it when everyone else was talking about them. Since then though, I pretty much only read books that call to me on some emotional level. If something jumps off the shelf at me then I’ll usually bring it home regardless of whether it’s a popular title or not. I’ve found some great reads that way, most recently Recovering Charles by Jason F. Wright. It’s such a deep story of hope and second chances that as soon as I read the teaser blurb I knew it was something I had to spend time with.

    Ruth | Oct 4, 2008 | Reply

Post a Comment